7 mai 2019 | Local, Aérospatial

U.S. threatens to pull F-35 from jet competition over industrial requirements

By

OTTAWA — U.S. officials have threatened to pull the F-35 out of the competition to replace the Royal Canadian Air Force's aging CF-18 fighters over the Liberal government's plan to ask bidders to re-invest some of the giant purchase contract in Canadian industry.

The warnings are in two letters sent to the government last year and obtained by defence analyst Richard Shimooka. They were released in a report published Monday by the Macdonald-Laurier Institute think-tank.

They say the requirement is incompatible with Canada's obligations as a member of the group of countries working together to develop the F-35 stealth fighter in the first place.

While the re-investment requirement is standard for most Canadian military procurements, the U.S. officials note Canada agreed not to include it when it signed on as one of nine F-35 partner countries in 2006.

Companies in those countries must instead compete for work associated with the plane — only companies from those countries are eligible, but they're supposed to compete on equal footing. The U.S. officials say conditions on bidders that would privilege Canadian companies will mean the F-35 won't be entered in the race.

The F-35, which is built by Lockheed Martin, had been expected to go up against the Eurofighter Typhoon, Saab Gripen and Boeing Super Hornet for an 88-plane procurement worth about $19 billion. French company Dassault pulled its Rafale from contention late last year.

"In summary, we cannot participate in an offer of the F-35 weapon system where requirements do not align with the F-35 partnership," U.S. Vice-Admiral Mathias Winter, program executive officer for the Pentagon's F-35 office, wrote on Dec. 18. "Such an offer would violate (the F-35 agreement) and place the entire F-35 partnership at risk."

In his letter to Paula Folkes-Dallaire, senior director of the fighter-jet program at Public Services and Procurement Canada, Winter asked for clarity by Jan. 31 as to the government's decision on the re-investment requirements.

Winter's letter followed a similar one from Ellen Lord, the Pentagon's head of military procurement, on Aug. 31, 2018.

In a statement, Public Procurement Minister Carla Qualtrough's spokeswoman said the government has engaged in several rounds of discussions and exchanges with potential bidders, which included providing them with opportunities "to ask questions, raise concerns and provide suggestions.

"Our government has been hard working to address as much of the supplier feedback as possible to ensure a level playing field and a fair and open competition with as many eligible suppliers as possible," added Ashley Michnowski.

"This stage of the process is not yet complete, though is nearing its conclusion and a final (request for proposals) will be issued soon."

The Pentagon's F-35 office did not return requests for comment.

Stephen Harper's Conservatives first announced plans to buy 65 F-35s without a competition in 2010, but backed off that plan over questions about cost and concerns over the Defence Department's tactics in getting government approval for the deal.

During the 2015 federal election campaign, Justin Trudeau's Liberals promised they would immediately launch an open and fair competition to replace the CF-18s, but not buy the F-35.

The Trudeau government has since said the F-35 will be allowed to compete while officials had been expecting to finally launch that competition in the coming weeks.

That the re-investment requirement remains unresolved is both surprising and unsurprising given defence experts have long warned it would be a significant obstacle to running a fair and open competition that includes the F-35.

Canada, which has already contributed roughly $500 million over the past 20 years toward developing the F-35, could in theory quit as a partner country, but would have to pay more for the stealth fighters if the F-35 won the competition.

Canada could also be on the hook for hundreds of millions more in development fees despite quitting the program, while Canadian companies would not be allowed to compete for work related to the aircraft.

In a recent interview, the Department of National Defence's head of military procurement, Patrick Finn, said the government is trying to strike the right balance between military and economic priorities when it comes to the fighter-jet competition.

"The feedback we're seeing from some suppliers some are quite content, some would like to see some more flexibility in other areas," he said.

"So it's making all of that work, respecting (companies') strengths, keeping everybody in the competition and doing it in a way that brings the right capability to the air force for decades to come."

—Follow @leeberthiaume on Twitter

Lee Berthiaume, The Canadian Press

https://www.nationalnewswatch.com/2019/05/06/ottawas-planned-fighter-competition-incompatible-with-f-35-obligations-u-s-3

Sur le même sujet

  • French firm Dassault pulls out of fighter-jet competition: Sources

    7 novembre 2018 | Local, Aérospatial

    French firm Dassault pulls out of fighter-jet competition: Sources

    By Lee Berthiaume The long effort to replace Canada's aging fighter jets took another surprise twist on Tuesday, as multiple sources revealed that French fighter-jet maker Dassault is pulling out of the multibillion-dollar competition. The decision comes just over a week after the federal government published the military's requirements for a replacement for Canada's CF-18s as well as a draft process by which a winning supplier will be chosen. Dassault had repeatedly pitched its Rafale aircraft to Canada over the years as successive governments in Ottawa have wrestled with selecting a new fighter jet. Dassault's pitch included significant promises, including that it would assemble the planes in Canada. But sources tell The Canadian Press that Dassault's decision to withdraw was related to the fact France is not a member of the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing network, which counts the U.S., Britain, Australia, New Zealand and Canada as members. The five members have very specific requirements for how their equipment works together. The French government, which had been closely working with Dassault as the most recent iteration of Canada's fighter-replacement program has inched along over the past year, was preparing to notify Ottawa of the company's withdrawal. The move leaves four companies — U.S. aerospace giants Lockheed Martin and Boeing, European competitor Airbus and Swedish firm Saab — competing for the $19-billion contract to replace Canada's 76 CF-18s with 88 new fighters. A contract isn't expected to be awarded until 2021 or 2022, with delivery of the first new aircraft slated for 2025. In the meantime, the government is planning to upgrade its CF-18s and buy 25 used fighters from Australia as a stopgap. Dassault faced several significant challenges in meeting Canada's requirements for a new fighter, said defence analyst David Perry of the Canadian Global Affairs Institute, and while they weren't insurmountable, they would have cost time and money. Those challenges included meeting those Five-Eyes intelligence-sharing requirements, which Perry said put Dassault at a distinct disadvantage in the competition when compared to Lockheed Martin, Boeing and, to a certain degree, Airbus. "For any of the non-American companies, solving the Five-Eyes interoperability issues is going to be challenging," he said, noting that the U.S. in particular is very sensitive about data-sharing. "And it costs companies a lot of money to mount and pursue bids. So if they think at this point in time that it's not a realistic prospect, then pulling out is pretty understandable." That could explain why Dassault never established a strong presence in Canada during the many years when it was trying to sell the Rafale as a replacement for the CF-18, he added. The CF-18s are about 35 years old. Canada's attempts to buy a new fighter jet have dragged on for nearly a decade after the previous Conservative government announced in 2010 that Canada would buy 65 F-35s without a competition, with the first to be delivered in 2015. But the Tories pushed the reset button in 2012 after the auditor general raised questions about the program and National Defence revealed the jets would cost $46 billion over their lifetimes. After campaigning on a promise not to buy the F-35s, the Trudeau Liberals announced in November 2016 they would take their time with a competition to replace the CF-18s, and buy 18 "interim" Boeing Super Hornets without a competition because Canada needed more fighter jets badly. But then Boeing's trade dispute with Canadian rival Bombardier saw the Liberals scrap their plan to buy Super Hornets and instead begin talks to buy 18 used fighter jets from Australia. A contract for those used planes is expected in the coming weeks. The formal competition to replace the CF-18s is scheduled to begin next spring. https://www.nationalobserver.com/2018/11/07/news/french-firm-dassault-pulls-out-fighter-jet-competition-sources

  • Canadian CH-147F Chinook crashed while executing turn shortly after clearing tree line: DND - Skies Mag

    29 août 2023 | Local, Aérospatial

    Canadian CH-147F Chinook crashed while executing turn shortly after clearing tree line: DND - Skies Mag

    Canada’s Department of National Defence Airworthiness Investigative Authority has issued the preliminary report into a fatal CH-47F Chinook helicopter crash.

  • La Marine royale canadienne aura un sixième Navire de patrouille extracôtier et de l’Arctique

    2 novembre 2018 | Local, Naval

    La Marine royale canadienne aura un sixième Navire de patrouille extracôtier et de l’Arctique

    Le 2 novembre 2018 – Halifax (Nouvelle-Écosse) – Défense nationale / Forces armées canadiennes Dans le cadre de Protection, Sécurité, Engagement : la politique de défense du Canada, le gouvernement du Canada fait l'acquisition de navires de patrouille extracôtiers et de l'Arctique (NPEA) pour renforcer les capacités de la Marine royale canadienne (MRC) tout en équipant nos femmes et nos hommes avec des navires polyvalents et fiables pour effectuer leurs indispensables missions. Aujourd'hui, l'honorable Harjit S. Sajjan, ministre de la Défense nationale, a annoncé que la MRC recevra un sixième navire de patrouille, ce qui aidera à maintenir des centaines d'emplois hautement qualifiés pour la classe moyenne. La MRC a besoin d'une flotte diversifiée pour réagir de façon appropriée aux défis auxquels elle fait face, aujourd'hui comme à l'avenir. Le NPEA patrouillera les océans du Canada, y compris l'Arctique, et il est parfaitement adapté aux missions à l'étranger qui touchent, entre autres, le soutien aux partenaires internationaux, l'aide humanitaire, le secours en cas de catastrophe, les activités de recherche et sauvetage et la lutte antidrogue. Un sixième navire de patrouille accroîtra considérablement la capacité de la MRC à déployer simultanément des NPEA, au pays ou à l'étranger. De plus, gr'ce à une flotte de six NPEA, nos frégates pourront se concentrer sur l'exécution d'autres t'ches, permettant ainsi à la MRC d'exploiter sa flotte de façon plus efficace. Le gouvernement du Canada est aussi résolu à offrir les meilleures possibilités économiques à la population canadienne. Comme énoncé dans la Stratégie nationale de construction navale, le gouvernement du Canada fournit à la MRC des navires sécuritaires et efficaces afin qu'elle puisse effectuer leurs missions, tout en fournissant à la population canadienne des opportunités économiques. Citations « Je me réjouis de confirmer aujourd'hui que notre Marine royale canadienne recevra un sixième navire de patrouille extracôtier et de l'Arctique, comme énoncé dans notre politique Protection, Sécurité, Engagement. Ce navire polyvalent améliorera les aptitudes de nos femmes et hommes qui navigueront à bord des NPEA, tout en renforçant la capacité opérationnelle future de la Marine. » Harjit S. Sajjan, ministre de la Défense nationale « La Stratégie nationale de construction navale continue de créer des bénéfices sociaux et économiques pour la population canadienne d'une côte à l'autre. La construction d'un sixième navire de patrouille extracôtier et de l'Arctique met en évidence notre engagement à maximiser la stabilité d'emploi pour les constructeurs navals hautement qualifies tout en supportant le travail nos braves femmes et hommes de la Marine royale canadienne. » Carla Qualtrough, ministre des Services publics et de l'Approvisionnement et de l'Accessibilité « Je ne saurais être plus satisfait de la décision de procéder à la construction d'un sixième navire. Ces navires extraordinaires assureront à la fois Protection, Sécurité, et Engagement de la marine canadienne. Ils accroîtront la capacité de la Marine royale canadienne à mener des activités dans le Nord, tout en continuant de contribuer à un large éventail d'opérations humanitaires, de sécurité, et de renforcement des capacités, au pays et dans le monde entier. » Vice-amiral Ron Lloyd, commandant de la Marine royale canadienne Faits en bref La décision de faire l'acquisition d'un sixième navire de patrouille extracôtier et de l'Arctique (NPEA) a été possible après s'être assuré du financement nécessaire pour l'acquisition de celui-ci et la modification de l'horaire de production. Les NPEA amélioreront considérablement les capacités des Forces armées canadiennes et leur présence dans l'Arctique, tout en accroissant leur présence sur les côtes de l'Atlantique et du Pacifique. Ainsi, la Marine royale canadienne pourra mieux exercer la souveraineté du Canada dans l'Arctique. Les NPEA constituent une plateforme hautement polyvalente pouvant être utilisée lors de diverses missions, tant au pays qu'à l'étranger, entre autres, surveillance côtière, recherche et sauvetage, lutte antidrogue, soutien aux partenaires internationaux, aide humanitaire et secours en cas de catastrophe. Trois navires sont en production; le début des travaux du quatrième navire est prévu cet hiver. Le premier NPEA devrait être livré à la Marine royale canadienne à l'été 2019. Liens connexes Navires de patrouille extracôtiers et de l'Arctique Le futur NCSM Harry DeWolf reçoit son nom officiel lors de son baptême NCSM Harry DeWolf Stratégie nationale de construction navale Retombées industrielles et technologiques Personnes-ressources Byrne Furlong Attachée de presse Cabinet du ministre de la Défense nationale 613-996-3100 Relations avec les médias Ministère de la Défense nationale Téléphone : 613-996-2353 Courriel : mlo-blm@forces.gc.ca https://www.canada.ca/fr/ministere-defense-nationale/nouvelles/2018/11/la-marine-royale-canadienne-aura-un-sixieme-navire-de-patrouille-extracotier-et-de-larctique.html

Toutes les nouvelles