20 août 2019 | Local, Aérospatial

Smol: Why Sweden is leagues ahead of Canada on fighter-jet technology

With the election looming, the Liberal government has set in motion, at least on paper, its commitment to consider bids for the purchase of new fighter jets. Of course, how committed the government is to move ahead on its renewed commitment remains to be seen.

Meanwhile, any Canadian truly committed to seeing a modern, well-equipped RCAF, supported by a capable military procurement program, should take special note of one of the top contenders to replace Canada's aging fleet of fighters: Sweden.

This non-aligned country, approximately the size of Newfoundland and Labrador, with a population only slightly larger than that of Quebec, has not only succeeded in developing generations of fighter jets, but has seen impressive success in exporting them.

Apart from Sweden, Saab's JAS 39 Gripen, the latest version released in 2016, is being used by the Czech Republic and Hungary within NATO. The governments of Brazil, South Africa and Thailand are also purchasing the aircraft. Other countries such as India, Botswana, Indonesia and the Philippines are seriously considering the Gripen.

But instead of fretting about how much Canada's aging fighters stand to potentially be outdone by the air forces of the developing world, we should instead look squarely at how Sweden came to be a serious contender to arm and equip this country's emaciated airforce.

We should instead look squarely at how Sweden came to be a serious contender to arm and equip this country's emaciated airforce.

The answer lies in the national mindset of the two countries. Unlike Canada, and especially when it comes to defence, Sweden refuses to allow itself to fall into dependency status vis-à-vis Europe, NATO or any other military power. In other words, while they actively cooperate with NATO in the defence of Europe, they make it clear that the defence of Sweden is first and foremost a Swedish responsibility. It is why the Swedish army, navy and airforce use high-tech equipment, much of which is built by the Swedes themselves. It is why the Swedes supplement their advanced military technology with elaborate defence-in-depth war plans and civil defence policies. The manual, “If crisis or war comes,” has been recently mailed to every household in Sweden.

By contrast, we Canadians have chosen a quasi-colonial mindset with respect to our defence, clearly reflected in our epically embarrassing procurement shortcomings and failures. For the last 60 years, beginning with the cancellation of the Avro Arrow, Canada has been falling into a pattern of dependency on the United States on all matters related to defence. Sweden, on the other hand, has remained committed to designing and developing much its own military aircraft, ships, submarines and army equipment.

In the mid-1950s, both Canada and Sweden were working independently on their own advanced fighter aircraft. While Canada was working on the Arrow, the Swedish military and engineers were hard at work on the Draken, which came out the same year. The Draken had a similar delta wing design to the Arrow and was the first European-built fighter jet to break the sound barrier.

But that is where the comparison ends; the two countries went on very different paths with respect to their airforces. Canada cancelled and destroyed its Arrow aircraft and took on second-rate Voodoo fighters from the United States. It is what we Canadians wanted, as no successive Conservative or Liberal government has since tried to “bring back the Arrow.”

Sweden aggressively continued development of new fighter technology, replacing the Draken with the Viggen in the 1970s, while Canada continued to try to squeeze more life out of our then-aging fighter jets. In the 1980s, as Canada was finally taking on the U.S built F-18, Sweden was working on the first version of the modern Gripen.

Of course, as had been well documented, the early Gripen had problems. But as with the Draken and Viggen, the Swedes, unlike Canada, stayed with their national fighter jet.

Today, Canada can only dream what our military aircraft industry might have been like in 2019 if then-prime minister John Diefenbaker, with the tacit support of the opposition Liberals, had not cancelled the Arrow, accelerating our descent into military dependency on the United States and national impotence on military procurement.

https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/columnists/smol-why-sweden-is-leagues-ahead-of-canada-on-fighter-jet-technology

Sur le même sujet

  • OPPORTUNITY: Meet with US DoD Foreign Comparative Testing Program at CANSEC 2023

    18 avril 2023 | Local, Autre défense

    OPPORTUNITY: Meet with US DoD Foreign Comparative Testing Program at CANSEC 2023

    The Canadian Defence Liaison Staff (Washington) and the Trade Commissioner Service would like to make Canada’s defence industry aware of an opportunity to meet with the US Department of Defense Foreign Comparative Testing (FCT) Program at CANSEC 2023! We ask that you share this message with your colleagues, contacts, and clients who may benefit from the FCT Program.   Interested firms should complete the attached Product Sheet and return to via email to LCdr Alain Gilbert - alain.gilbert@forces.gc.ca – (with a CC to Trade Commissioner Bobby Tate – Robert.tate@interational.gc.ca) by Friday, May 12th.   The FCT program scans for vendors in non-US countries that have innovative technologies that speak to the US DoD’s 14 Critical Technology Areas. Please note that the Critical Technology Areas have been updated for 2023:   o          Biotechnology o          Quantum Science o          Future Generation Wireless Technology (FutureG) o          Advanced Materials o          Trusted AI and Autonomy o          Integrated Network Systems-of-Systems o          Microelectronics o          Space Technology o          Renewable Energy and Storage o          Advanced computing and Software o          Human-Machine Interfaces o          Directed Energy o          Hypersonic o          Integrated Sensing and Cyber   The USD(R&E) Technology Vision for an Era of Competition provides additional context. It can be found here: https://www.cto.mil/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/usdre_strategic_vision_critical_tech_areas.pdf   DoD will also consider technologies that satisfy urgent operational needs on a relevant fielding schedule and/or technologies that provide significant life cycle savings. In short, they’re looking for technology that does an existing capability better, cheaper, or faster!   For more information, an overview presentation on the FCT program can be found here: https://ac.cto.mil/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/fct_overview_presentation_approved_7_14_2020.pdf   Companies who submit a product template may have the opportunity to meet with the FCT program during the CANSEC exposition  (31 May – 1 June 2023).  The expo will be held at the EY Centre in Ottawa, Ontario. Again, interested firms should complete the attached FCT Product Sheet, and send it to LCdr Alain Gilbert, A/Defence Cooperation Attaché at alain.gilbert@forces.gc.ca with a CC to Bobby Tate at Robert.tate@international.gc.ca   We hope you consider this opportunity to learn more about the U.S. Department of Defense’s FCT program.   Questions may be addressed to LCdr Alain Gilbert, Assistant Defence Cooperation Attaché at alain.gilbert@forces.gc.ca and Mr. Bobby Tate, Trade Commissioner, Defense, Security, and Aerospace, at robert.tate@international.gc.ca

  • CADSI Report: Greater collaboration on military cyber-defence essential for keeping Canada safe from foreign attacks

    14 mars 2019 | Local, C4ISR, Sécurité

    CADSI Report: Greater collaboration on military cyber-defence essential for keeping Canada safe from foreign attacks

    New CADSI Report: Greater collaboration on military cyber-defence essential for keeping Canada safe from foreign attacks OTTAWA, ON March 7, 2019 – Canada's current military procurement models and levels of industry-government cooperation have not kept pace with the unprecedented “speed of cyber” and could compromise national security if left unaddressed, a new report from the Canadian Association of Defence and Security Industries (CADSI) concludes. The report, entitled From Bullets to Bytes: Industry's Role in Preparing Canada for the Future of Cyber Defence , was made public today. It outlines some of the challenges associated with preparing and equipping the Canadian Armed Forces for a modern battlefield where the physical and digital are seamlessly merged. “Warfare has changed,” said CADSI President Christyn Cianfarani. “Our military is moving rapidly into a future where cyber-defence will be essential for protecting Canada and Canadian military missions abroad. How industry and government work together and get decisive cyber technologies into the hands of Canadian soldiers and intelligence agencies must change, too.” Based on a year of research and 70 interviews with government, military and industry leaders in the field, From Bullets to Bytes confirms that there are dozens of Canadian firms with cyber-defence expertise that could be leveraged by DND as it invests billions in cyber-defence programs and procurements over the next decade. The report notes, however, that government and industry still lack formal mechanisms to communicate, collaborate and build trust – and procurement cycles can take years. “Our adversaries can deploy new cyber capabilities in a matter of months, or even days," said Ms. Cianfarani. “For Canada to win on the cyber-enabled battlefield, Canadian government and industry must collaborate intentionally, the way our allies do. Now is the time to lean on Canada's national security innovation base and overhaul the procurement process to work at cyber-speed.” CADSI's report outlines a path forward, offering five core recommendations that the association believes will move Canada's military toward cyber-readiness. These include setting up a secure Canadian cyber-defence network to facilitate collaboration, increasing the pool of available experts to be used as cyber reservists, and overhauling the government's classification system and capabilities database. https://www.defenceandsecurity.ca/media/article&id=346&t=c

  • Des technologies canadiennes en route vers la Lune!

    13 décembre 2022 | Local, Aérospatial

    Des technologies canadiennes en route vers la Lune!

    Des pays du monde entier se préparent à retourner sur la Lune et le Canada joue un rôle majeur dans cette grande initiative inspirante. Ce matin à 2 h 38 HE, deux technologies canadiennes ont été lancées vers la Lune à bord d'une fusée Falcon 9 de SpaceX dans le cadre de Mission 1 de l'entreprise japonaise ispace. Canadensys Aerospace Corporation (Canadensys) et Mission Control testeront leurs technologies de pointe afin de s'assurer qu'elles résisteront aux conditions hostiles de la Lune. Cette mission commerciale se posera sur la Lune au printemps 2023. Canadensys fournira à cette mission un système d'imagerie à 360° doté d'intelligence artificielle et de plusieurs caméras. Ce système résistant aux conditions hostiles de l'environnement lunaire sera notamment utilisé pour prendre des images de chacun des rovers de l'Agence japonaise d'exploration spatiale et du centre spatial Mohammed-bin-Rashid des Émirats arabes unis, à mesure qu'ils s'éloignent de l'atterrisseur d'ispace en direction opposée. L'entreprise Mission Control fera la démonstration d'un ordinateur de vol doté d'intelligence artificielle pour classifier les caractéristiques géologiques pendant le déplacement d'un rover. Habituellement, cette classification est réalisée sur Terre. Ce système pourrait ouvrir de nouvelles possibilités : les rovers pourraient exécuter eux-mêmes certaines choses, par exemple pour ce qui est de la navigation et de la classification du terrain. Une troisième entreprise, NGC Aérospatiale Ltée, recevra de l'imagerie de cette mission pour tester son système de positionnement semblable à la technologie GPS utilisée sur Terre. Elle s'en servira aussi pour préparer une future mission où cette technologie guidera les véhicules lunaires vers un endroit précis où ils pourront atterrir en toute sécurité. L'Agence spatiale canadienne a financé ces trois projets dans le cadre du Programme d'accélération de l'exploration lunaire. Grâce à ce financement, les entreprises auront sept occasions différentes de tester leurs technologies sur la Lune ou en orbite lunaire au cours des prochaines années. Citations « Aujourd'hui, grâce au soutien de l'Agence spatiale canadienne, deux technologies canadiennes révolutionnaires ont été lancées à bord de la Mission 1 de l'entreprise ispace. Ce lancement est un autre exemple d'entreprises canadiennes qui sont des figures de proue de cette nouvelle ère des plus palpitantes de l'exploration spatiale. Ces technologies contribueront à renforcer les capacités au Canada et à réduire les coûts des missions, tout en positionnant notre pays comme un partenaire de choix dans de futures initiatives spatiales. » - L'honorable François-Philippe Champagne, ministre de l'Innovation, des Sciences et de l'Industrie Faits en bref En 2019, le Canada a annoncé sa participation au prochain chapitre de l'histoire de l'exploration de la Lune. Le Programme d'accélération de l'exploration lunaire prépare le secteur spatial canadien au retour des êtres humains sur la Lune grâce à un investissement de 150 millions de dollars sur cinq ans pour aider les petites et moyennes entreprises canadiennes à mettre au point de nouvelles technologies qui seront utilisées et testées en orbite lunaire et sur la Lune. Un total de 3,3 millions de dollars en contributions a été accordé à Canadensys (2,49 millions de dollars) et à NGC Aérospatiale Ltée. (726 000 dollars) en 2020. Une contribution de 3 millions de dollars a été accordée à Mission Control en 2021. En 2019, le secteur spatial canadien a soutenu près de 23 000 emplois (directs et indirects) et contribué pour 2,5 milliards de dollars à l'économie canadienne. Les PME constituent 94 % des entreprises du secteur spatial canadien. https://www.canada.ca/fr/agence-spatiale/nouvelles/2022/11/des-technologies-canadiennes-en-route-vers-la-lune.html

Toutes les nouvelles