Retour aux nouvelles

27 juin 2019 | International, Autre défense

Lockheed braces for German blowback over cost of missile-defense pitch

By:

PARIS — Lockheed Martin executives are preparing for a stiff debate in Germany about the price tag of a next-generation anti-missile system formally proposed to Berlin just days ago.

“I think the price will be a challenge, and we'll have to negotiate to come to an agreement,” Frank St. John, executive vice president of the company's Missiles and Fire Control business, told Defense News in an interview at the Paris Air Show last week. “But we're going to do better than the early expectations of the price.”

That is a reference to a figure that surfaced during the spring following testimony of a senior German defense official before parliament. At the time, the cost estimate for the TLVS program, short for Taktisches Luftverteidigungssystem, was €8 billion (U.S. $9 billion).

St. John declined to name the price ultimately included by Lockheed Martin and its German partner MBDA in their June 21 proposal. But he suggested the figure would lie significantly enough below the €8 million mark to be considered more than cosmetic.

“I still anticipate a healthy debate and discussion about the pricing and the scope of the program through the negotiation process,” he said.

Negotiations are expected to begin as soon as the German Defence Ministry has analyzed the proposal, described by German officials as being thousands of pages long. If the government and Lockheed Martin come to an agreement, the proposed investment would go before lawmakers for a decision, probably late this year or early next year.

German plans for the TLVS program are based on the Medium Extended Air Defense System, conceived about 10 years ago as a replacement for the Patriot fleets of the United States, Germany and Italy. Soldiers had criticized the decades-old Patriot system as too cumbersome to deploy and maintain in the field.

Germany has stuck with MEADS even after the United States and Italy dropped off, with officials in Berlin arguing the prospect of developing a truly novel defensive weapon was worth the gamble of going it alone.

Defense officials in Germany have since added new requirements. For one, Berlin wants full control over all components, as opposed to buying an American weapon whose inner workings are shrouded in secrecy. In addition, the German government wants to be able to shoot down what officials call “advanced threats” (code for hypersonic missiles, such as those developed by Russia).

According to St. John, Lockheed's latest TLVS proposal comes with the promise of intercepting such threats, though probably not the most sophisticated ones. “And then there is a provision in the contract and in the design of the system to add capability as time goes by and as the threat evolves,” he said.

One of the sticking points for the proposed program — German access to secret performance data of the weapon's principal interceptor, the so-called MSE missile — appears to have been resolved, St. John said. Until late last year, Berlin was unhappy with U.S. Army restrictions placed on the information, which Germany considers crucial for adapting the system to its needs.

Senior Pentagon leaders intervened to help resolve the logjam after Defense News reported on the issue in December 2018.

“We believe that we have coordinated that with the Department of State and the appropriate folks at the Department of Defense, and that the German customer is going to have access to the data they need to evaluate the system,” St. John said. “They'll also have access to the data they need to recommend future modifications. We think that issue is resolved now.”

At the same time, he added, another round of approvals will be needed from the U.S. government as contract negotiations with Germany progress. “We'll have to go back one more time ... to verify that everything is still in a good place."

Patriot-maker Raytheon issued a statement Monday reiterating its readiness to snatch the missile-defense contract from arch enemy Lockheed Martin if the TLVS program goes south. The company especially played up the option of connecting an upgraded Patriot system to a lower-tier system, made by Rheinmetall, to defend against drones and artillery rounds.

Ralph Acaba, president of Raytheon's Integrated Defense Systems business, said his company is increasingly banking on a layered air defense concept in which different systems — perhaps owned by different countries — take on various threat types. “No single nation, no single system can do it all when it comes to missile defense,” he told Defense News at the Paris Air Show.

According to Joseph de Antona, vice president for business development and strategy in Acaba's division, Raytheon does not consider Lockheed's TLVS bid a threat to Patriot sales. “If a country makes a decision, it's our responsibility to honor and recognize that,” he said. At the same time, he added, Raytheon plans to continue to advise the German government on new threats and how to counter them.

The company is “absolutely” still talking to the Berlin government to that effect, de Antona told Defense News.

German lawmakers on the Defence and Budget committees on Wednesday approved roughly €120 million to upgrade the country's Patriot fleet to the newest configuration, known as “3-plus.” According to Raytheon, Berlin's investments to keep Patriot up to date had been lagging since the decision in favor of TLVS.

Meanwhile, the proposed new system's funding profile has begun to take shape. Berlin wants to spend €3.36 billion on TLVS between 2021 and 2028, according to a draft government budget proposal meant for deliberation by lawmakers after the summer recess.

That figure likely would be too low to finance Lockheed's entire program proposal. But the draft budget includes a provision permitting a transfer of funds from the envisioned €5.6 billion budget for a new heavy transport helicopter.

The two contenders for that program are Boeing and Lockheed Martin.

https://www.defensenews.com/digital-show-dailies/paris-air-show/2019/06/26/lockheed-braces-for-german-blowback-over-cost-of-missile-defense-pitch/

Sur le même sujet

  • Key debate on military protest response, budget priorities set to happen behind closed doors on Capitol Hill

    9 juin 2020 | International, Aérospatial, Naval, Terrestre, C4ISR, Sécurité

    Key debate on military protest response, budget priorities set to happen behind closed doors on Capitol Hill

    Leo Shane III The biggest defense news on Capitol Hill this week will be taking place behind the scenes rather than in public view, as lawmakers grapple with the military's response to recent nationwide protests and their own plans for next year's Pentagon budget. On Monday, Army Secretary Ryan McCarthy, Army Chief of Staff Gen. James McConville and District of Columbia National Guard Commander Maj. Gen. William Walker will brief members of the House Armed Services Committee in a non-public meeting. The session was originally scheduled for late last week, amid concerns that guardsmen may have overstepped their roles as security support for D.C. police responding to some of the massive racial equality demonstrations outside the White House in recent days. The protests were sparked by the death of George Floyd, a black man prosecutors say was murdered by a white Minneapolis police officer. Since then, Pentagon officials appear to have tamped down President Donald Trump's suggestions that active-duty troops should be brought in to help handle the work, creating a massive show of force to “dominate” the streets of major cities across the country. But House Armed Services Committee members have said they still have lingering questions about how those discussions progressed, and whether guardsmen were put in an uncomfortable political role instead of their traditional support response. Democratic members are also sparring with Defense Secretary Mark Esper and Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Mark Milley, after committee Chairman Adam Smith, D-Wash., vowed to bring the Pentagon leaders to Capitol Hill for a full public hearing on the issues this week. Esper and Milley have thus far refused, although Pentagon officials said they are negotiating scheduling issues for a possible future appearance. “The DoD legislative affairs team remains in discussion with the HASC on this request," Navy Cmdr. Sean Robertson, a Pentagon spokesman, said last week. "In the meantime, DoD has committed to provide Army Secretary McCarthy, Army Chief of Staff Gen. McConville, and D.C. National Guard Commanding General Maj. Gen. Walker to brief the committee next week on the presence of the National Guard in Washington, D.C., this past week.” Smith and 30 other Democratic committee members called Esper's refusal to appear this week “unacceptable.” Several members of the committee have vowed to include the issue in the annual defense authorization bill. Subcommittee mark-ups of the massive military budget policy measure are scheduled to begin on June 22. The Senate Armed Services Committee is beginning its mark-up of the authorization bill this week, with the first two subcommittee section votes scheduled for Monday afternoon. The full committee mark-up will take place starting on Wednesday. Unlike their House counterparts, however, nearly all of that work will be done behind closed doors. Senate committee officials have said in the past that they can more quickly and efficiently navigate the hundreds of legislative issues within the bill if they keep the work out of public view, to allow seamless transition between classified and non-classified topics. The only portion of the Senate authorization bill work to be made public will be the personnel subcommittee mark-up, set for Tuesday at 2 p.m. The hearing will be streamed through the committee's web site, as restrictions on public access to the Capitol complex remain in place because of the coronavirus pandemic. The House Armed Services Committee will have a public hearing on a separate topic later this week: Ellen Lord, Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment, will testify on Wednesday about the impact of the ongoing pandemic on the defense industrial base. https://www.militarytimes.com/news/pentagon-congress/2020/06/08/key-debate-on-military-protest-response-budget-priorities-set-to-happen-behind-closed-doors-on-capitol-hill/

  • Thales lance Iven, une marketplace pour fédérer les achats des acteurs défense et civil

    25 septembre 2020 | International, Aérospatial, Naval, Terrestre, C4ISR

    Thales lance Iven, une marketplace pour fédérer les achats des acteurs défense et civil

    AUDE CHARDENON Thales a lancé début septembre une place de marché baptisée Iven. Destinée à mettre en relation vendeurs et acheteurs de l'environnement Défense et Civil, elle implique un nouveau métier pour le géant français. Les détails de Pascal Geoffroy, directeur enhanced customer operations services. Thales devient un commerçant. Le géant industriel français a lancé début septembre une plateforme B2B qui met en relation les clients et les principaux fournisseurs d'articles dédiés à l'environnement Défense et Civil quel que soit le milieu : aérospatial, terrestre ou naval. Fonctionnant selon un modèle de marketplace, Iven – pour Intermediation vendor entreprise – a nécessité deux ans de travail. Lancée le 1er septembre, Iven est un service en ligne dédié aux Industriels souhaitant optimiser leurs approvisionnements. La plateforme compte à date 150 000 références. On y trouve notamment des consommables industriels (pièces détachées), et actualité oblige, des produits liés à la situation sanitaire. DIGITALISER LA SUPPLY CHAIN DE BOUT EN BOUT Iven n'est pas née par hasard. En 2018, l'entreprise se retrouve face à un constat. "Nous avons gagné un gros contrat de supply chain, et nous nous sommes rendus compte que nous devions être plus fluides et plus rapides. Très rapidement, la marketplace nous a paru être la solution pour mettre en relation acheteurs et vendeurs pour de futurs contrats de même nature", explique en préambule Pascal Geoffroy, Directeur Enhanced Customer Operations Services chez Thales. Vient alors l'idée de transformer la supply chain de bout en bout et de "digitaliser les achats pour être compétitif", avec la mise en ligne des catalogues des marchands et par conséquent l'abandon des canaux offline (devis, contrats, téléphone/mail...), la fin de la logique transactionnelle impliquant une négociation pour chaque commande, et la digitalisation du workflow, permettant un gain de temps pour le traitement administratif. THALES, TIERS DE CONFIANCE Iven fonctionne comme une plateforme e-commerce classique. Les marchands y mettent en visibilité leurs produits et leurs offres (prix, disponibilité, conditions de vente...). L'acheteur consulte et compare les différentes offres répondant à son besoin, puis il passe sa commande. Le règlement est effectué par virement à Iven, l'encaissement se déroulant via un intermédiaire financier indépendant. Iven supervise la transaction. La commande est ensuite expédiée et livrée directement par le marchand sur le site client. L'ensemble du parcours est digitalisé, du sourcing jusqu'à la livraison. La solution s'appuie sur l'expertise de différents sous-traitants, dont Mirakl. L'enjeu pour Thales est de se positionner "en tiers de confiance" pour les grands comptes ainsi que pour des organismes d'Etat. Dans un écosystème où intervient parfois le secret-défense, Iven ne peut être, et ne sera pas, une place de marché comme les autres. "Thales se positionne comme un tiers de confiance notamment en matière de cybersécurité, où la fiabilisation des échanges est essentielle", rappelle Pascal Geoffroy. Pour ce faire, l'équipe va "sélectionner les vendeurs et les acheteurs. Il en va de la crédibilité de cette marketplace", insiste-t-il. DES MARKETPLACES PRIVÉES POUR LES GRANDS FOURNISSEURS Fournisseurs qualifiés par Thales, articles certifiés, crédibilité financière... Le paiement est conditionné à la réception, et des technologies de cybersécurité sont garanties pour assurer l'intégrité et la confidentialité des données. Iven jouera d'ailleurs un rôle d'intermédiation en cas de litige. Outre le cas d'usage classique évoqué plus haut, Iven propose aux fournisseurs de construire leur propre marketplace via un système d'onboarding du catalogue privé et des marchands spécifiques. Le lancement d'Iven n'était pas forcément acquis pour une société comme Thales. "C'est un nouveau métier pour Thales, et un nouveau métier de la supply chain", reconnaît Pascal Geoffroy. Pourtant, le rôle fédérateur du groupe, à la croisée du monde militaire et civil, en fait l'interlocuteur privilégié de nombreux acteurs, y compris des PME-ETI. "Le tissu industriel est très fragmenté, il est composé de beaucoup de petites structures, analyse Pascal Geoffroy. Et je suis très attaché à développer cet écosystème dont font partie les PME, qui n'ont pas toujours la puissance de se développer en ligne, y compris à l'international". Iven va en effet être déployée dans cinq pays européens limitrophes à la France, avec des ambitions ultérieures bien plus vastes. Iven s'enrichira d'outils de monitoring de la performance fournisseur ainsi que de fonctionnalités algorithmiques dédiées à l'optimisation des achats. La plateforme pourra se connecter d'ici quelques mois aux ERP des grands comptes. A moyen terme, Iven vise 100 marchands. "Le secteur de la défense est un monde fermé, en retard en matière de transformation digitale par rapport au civil. Cela va secouer certains acteurs", prévient Pascal Geoffroy.

  • NATO customer Norway officially commissions new high-performance Rheinmetall MAN logistic vehicles

    1 septembre 2022 | International, Terrestre

    NATO customer Norway officially commissions new high-performance Rheinmetall MAN logistic vehicles

    The first shipments of trucks earmarked for Norway include 109 vehicles of various types

Toutes les nouvelles