25 octobre 2018 | International, Naval

For Europe, it’s naval business as usual

By: Tom Kington , Pierre Tran , Andrew Chuter , and Sebastian Sprenger

Is there enough drive to reach a unified shipbuilding enterprise?

ROME, LONDON, PARIS AND COLOGNE, Germany — As European shipbuilders prepare to transform their nations' rising military budgets into naval power, local priorities are acting as formidable forces against the integration of a fragmented market.

Two years ago, Italian defense think tank CESI produced a document lamenting the fractured state of the European naval industry, warning that firms on the continent would be swept aside by foreign competition if they failed to team up and take on the world.

The paper provided the ideological underpinning for proposals by Italian shipyard Fincantieri to jointly build vessels with France's Naval Group, a plan being considered by both governments.

But today, one of the authors of the report, Francesco Tosato, says that despite European Union moves to integrate the defense industry, little has changed in the naval sector.

“We still have six or eight types of frigates, each with manufacturing runs of no more than 10 vessels, which is unsustainable,” he said. Supporters of integration say shipyards will be able to cut costs through synergies and avoid competing against each other in export markets.

“The Germans are building U-212NG submarines with the Norwegians, but they are not integrating,” he added.

A second analyst agreed that integration is not happening, but offered a positive outlook.

“With European governments not wanting to spend on naval vessels, it is all about exports, and buyers in Asia and the Middle East want to deal with one government, not with Europe,” said Peter Roberts, director of military sciences at the Royal United Services Institute in London.

“They may want a German frigate with a French radar and MBDA missiles, but they still want one national point of contact,” he added.

Roberts also argued that European multinational shipbuilders risked stifling competition. “That could lead to poorer designs and higher prices,” he said.

In addition, one European industrial giant may be unable to offer different types of vessels to export customers with a variety of requirements.

“Customers have bespoke needs, which means systems integrators are crucial,” Roberts said. “Why not have systems intergrators working on a European basis? That could be the starting point for integrating Europe's industry, rather than putting together shipyards.”

German angst

In Germany, meanwhile, industry officials and lawmakers are bickering over whether surface shipbuilding is, or should be, a national priority so critical that contracts must go to German yards. (The Ministry of Defence has only designated submarine construction as such a key capability.)

That debate permeates the competition for the MKS-180 program, a novel multi-use combat ship. The thought that Dutch contractor Damen, one of the bidders still in the race, could win the contract over the purely German team of German Naval Yards and ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems has some coastal politicians and trade unions up in arms.

There is a lot at stake for German shipbuilders. A recent MoD strategy document proclaimed a national objective of restoring the balance between out-of-area missions and homeland defense. The latter area has been chronically underfunded in the rush to provide troops at the tip of the spear with equipment that works, the argument goes.

That dynamic will “inevitably mean an increase in forces, including warships and modernization of the fleet,” a spokesman for the Germany Navy told Defense News.

For example, the service plans to buy at least one new warship annually over the next 10 years, plus 46 helicopters. Combined with a new deployment and manning scheme, officials hope to raise the entire fleet's operational availability to 50 percent compared with today's 30 percent, meaning more vessels theoretically will be ready to fight at any given time.

Those plans could directly translate into jobs in Germany, and domestic shipbuilders, including heavyweight TKMS, are doing their part to support the demand for government favoritism toward their own yards.

British exclusivity

The situation is similar in the United Kingdom, where shipbuilding for the Royal Navy is by definition a domestic affair.

It has been a little more than a year since the British government published a national shipbuilding strategy, which in part called for a greater surface warship building capability.

BAE Systems has had a stranglehold on the business since it first merged and then in 2009 acquired VT Shipbuilding.

BAE Systems' two surface warship building yards in Glasgow, Scotland, meet the government requirement that complex warships must be locally built.

The Conservative government, however, made it clear in its shipbuilding strategy that while BAE would continue to build in Glasgow the planned eight Type 26 anti-submarine warfare frigates destined for the Royal Navy, it wanted another yard to build a fleet of five Type 31e general purpose frigates.

Peter Parker, the author of the strategy report, justified the creation of a second naval build center, saying it would be unprecedented for BAE to run two new programs side by side.

But it hasn't been smooth sailing for British Ministry of Defence officials running the Type 31e program, as they seek sufficient bidders to hold a robust competition. Building frigates in a British yard with a price of no more than £250 million (U.S. $329 million) and an in-service date of 2023 has proved a challenge.

The government stopped the competition earlier this year after it failed to attract a sufficient level of interest from qualified vendors. But officials got the show back on the road Aug. 20, restarting discussions with potential suppliers on a revised plan. Competition documents were issued to industry last month, with potential bidders mandated to reply by Oct. 19.

With German and the British shipyards hoping to secure their respective turfs at home, the Fincantieri-Naval Group deal could still become the poster child for European naval-industry consolidation.

At least, that's the theory.

French maneuvers

French officials appeared to get cold feet earlier this month on a key aspect of the merger arrangement: a proposed cross-shareholding of 5 to 10 percent.

“Bercy is not keen,” said an industry executive, referring to the French Economy and Finance Ministry, located in a vast modern building resembling a bridge by the river Seine.

A source with the French Armed Forces Ministry would only say: “Negotiations take time. We need more time.”

Even before that wrinkle, the French and Italian governments requested “clarification” from Fincantieri and Naval Group after the two companies submitted dossiers in mid-July for a partnership.

The request for clarification referred to the key elements of cooperation in research and development, common purchase of parts and offers in export markets, an industry executive told Defense News.

Cross-border cooperation in foreign sales is seen as significant, as Naval Group has set a target of exports accounting for half of annual sales compared to the present estimated one-third of revenue.

Competition with Fincantieri raises the cost of sales and cuts profit margins, as each seeks to submit competitive offers.

If Naval Group and Fincantieri do manage to forge an industrial alliance, that will reverse a declining trend in cooperation. Previous French attempts to work with Italy in building a common MU90 light torpedo led to nothing, while the level of common parts on the FREMM multimission frigate fell compared to that realized on the Horizon air-defense frigate.

European industrial cooperation also stalled on the Scorpene attack submarine, with Spanish shipbuilder Navantia opting to pursue its own S-80 diesel-electric boat rather than work with Naval Group.

Tom Kington, Andrew Chuter, Pierre Tran and Sebastian Sprenger contributed to this report.

https://www.defensenews.com/global/europe/2018/10/21/for-europe-its-naval-business-as-usual/

Sur le même sujet

21 décembre 2020 | International, C4ISR

LE NOUVEAU PARTENARIAT ENTRE INDRA ET THALES PERMETTRA D'OFFRIR DES COMMUNICATIONS TACTIQUES DE NOUVELLE GÉNÉRATION AUX FORCES ARMÉES ESPAGNOLES
Thales et Indra ont signé un protocole d'accord en vue de proposer un système radio tactique interarmées (JTRS) qui garantira la souveraineté et l'autonomie technologique des forces armées espagnoles • Cette offre s'inscrit dans le cadre du programme espagnol de renouvellement de son système de communications tactiques et propose de développer une solution nationale basée sur une technologie radio logicielle éprouvée • La proposition inclut également un plan pour accélérer la spécialisation de l'industrie espagnole dans les activités à valeur ajoutée et renforcer sa compétitivité globale Madrid, le 18 décembre 2020 – En réponse à la décision prise par l'Espagne en vue de renouveler les infrastructures existantes du pays, Indra et Thales, deux des principales entreprises high tech européennes dans le secteur de la défense, ont signé un protocole d'accord pour proposer ensemble aux forces armées espagnoles un système de communications tactiques de nouvelle génération. Ce système permettra notamment d'améliorer l'interopérabilité lors des missions internationales, et d'assurer la souveraineté et l'autonomie technologique des forces armées en termes de communications stratégiques. La supériorité sur l'ennemi, dans le cadre des thé'tres d'opération actuels, dépend d'un échange d'informations rapide, agile et sécurisé. Les plateformes et les véhicules, de plus en plus intelligents, sont aujourd'hui équipés de capteurs dotés d'une extrême précision, capables de collecter un fort volume de données et d'opérer en réseau avec d'autres systèmes. Les actions menées conjointement avec les forces d'autres pays se traduisent par une complexité technologique accrue sur les thé'tres. Dans ce type de scénarios : les radios logicielles (software-defined radio - SDR) constituent un facteur clé pour assurer le succès d'une armée moderne. Les forces armées les plus avancées vont se tourner vers les radios logicielles dans les prochaines années pour assurer leurs capacités de transmission, avec des échanges d'information rapides et sécurisés, et la souplesse requise pour des interopérations efficaces avec les forces alliées. Souveraineté, soutien et plan industriel pour l'industrie espagnole L'offre élaborée par Indra et Thales comprend le développement de produits et de solutions high tech en Espagne, sur la base d'une solution Thales déjà éprouvée. Les nouveaux produits s'appuieront sur sa gamme de systèmes radio SYNAPS, renforcée par de nouvelles fonctionnalités mises en œuvre avec Indra. L'expertise d'Indra et de Thales en termes de matériels et de logiciels radio, ainsi que leur expérience des opérations, permettront aux deux entreprises d'offrir aux forces armées espagnoles un soutien et des services adéquats tout au long du cycle de vie des produits. Le plan industriel qui fait partie intégrante de l'offre permettra d'accélérer la spécialisation des entreprises espagnoles dans des activités à plus forte valeur ajoutée, allant au-delà de la fabrication et l'assemblage de solutions proposées par des tierces parties. S'il est mis en œuvre, il permettra aux entreprises espagnoles d'être plus compétitives sur les marchés internationaux, avec le maintien d'emplois durables dans le pays, tout en renforçant le savoir-faire national et son autonomie technologique. Le partenariat établi entre Indra et Thales se traduira par des avantages mutuels significatifs, venant renforcer le portefeuille de solutions d'Indra, et consolider l'implantation industrielle de Thales dans le secteur de la défense en Espagne. A propos de Indra Indra est l'une des principales entreprises de consulting et de technologie au monde, et le partenaire technologique des activités stratégiques de ses clients à l'international. La société propose une offre complète de solutions propriétaires dans des segments spécifiques des marchés du transport et de la défense. Indra est un leader international dans le secteur de la défense, avec le développement des projets critiques pour la défense nationale des pays que l'entreprise accompagne, pour sa participation dans des programmes européens majeurs dans le cadre de l'OTAN, ainsi que pour ses capacités à l'export. Indra est, en Espagne, le coordinateur national du programme européen de défense NGWS/FCAS. Indra est également une entreprise de pointe dans le conseil en transformation digitale et dans les technologies de l'information, en Espagne et en Amérique latine, via sa filiale Minsait. Implantée dans 46 pays, et opérant dans plus de 140 pays, Indra a enregistré en 2019 un chiffre d'affaires de 3 204 millions d'euros avec 49 000 employés. www.indracompany.com A propos de Thales Thales (Euronext Paris : HO) est un leader mondial de hautes technologies qui façonne aujourd'hui le monde de demain. Le Groupe propose des solutions, services et produits à ses clients dans les domaines de l'aéronautique, de l'espace, du transport, de l'identité et sécurité numériques, et de la défense. Avec 83 000 collaborateurs dans 68 pays, Thales a réalisé un chiffre d'affaires de 19 milliards d'euros en 2019 (sur une base intégrant Gemalto sur 12 mois). Thales investit notamment dans les innovations numériques - connectivité, big data, intelligence artificielle et cybersécurité – technologies au cœur des moments décisifs des entreprises, des organisations et des Etats. En Espagne, avec plus de 1 400 collaborateurs, Thales apporte son expertise aux clients dans les secteurs de la défense, de l'aéronautique, de l'espace, de l'identité et sécurité numériques et du transport. Les activités de défense sont assurées via la société Thales Programas de Electrónica y Comunicaciones, basée à Leganés (Madrid). https://www.thalesgroup.com/fr/group/journaliste/press_release/le-nouveau-partenariat-entre-indra-et-thales-permettra-doffrir-des#:~:text=Madrid%2C%20le%2018%20d%C3%A9cembre%202020,proposer%20ensemble%20aux%20forces%20arm%C3%A9es
2 novembre 2018 | International, Naval

LEONARDO TO EQUIP THE NEW GERMAN CORVETTES 130 WITH ITS BEST IN CLASS DEFENCE SYSTEMS
With this contract, Leonardo's OTO 76/62 Super Rapid becomes the reference defence system for the German Navy Managed by a state of the art control console maximizing its performances, the system can be integrated on any type and class of ship, including smaller units The OTO 76/62 SR system is a best in class in its segment, in use with almost 60 Navies worldwide. It has recently successfully completed an extensive vulnerability assessment campaign ensuring its resilience to cyber-attacks Leonardo signed a contract with the Bundesamt für Ausrüstung, Informationstechnik und Nutzung der Bundeswehr, the German Federal Office in charge of defence acquisitions, to provide seven OTO 76/62 Super Rapid systems that will equip the new K130 corvettes of the German Navy. The contract also includes training and spare parts supply. With this new acquisition, Leonardo's naval gun becomes the reference defence system for the German Navy, which has already tested the capabilities of the compact version of the system, integrated on the first batch of corvettes following a previous contract. The signing of the contract strengthens the historical collaboration with the country and with the Agency. Leonardo has indeed provided the first naval artillery systems, in particular the 76/62 Compact, starting from the 70s; the most recent supplies include the 127/64 Vulcano naval guns and the Hitrole 12.7 turrets currently on board the F125 Frigate. The OTO 76/62 SR system, part of Leonardo's naval artillery offer, represents a commercial success. In service with almost 60 Navies worldwide, the system is the only medium-calibre, together with compact version, capable of sustaining a fire rate of up to 120 strokes per minute, a fundamental requirement for defence in asymmetrical war scenarios. It is characterised by the lightweight, accuracy and use of guided ammunition. The flexibility of use makes it particularly suitable for anti-aircraft and anti-missile defence and for point defence. It can be integrated on any type and class of ship, including smaller units. Depending on the configuration, the OTO 76/62 Super Rapid could include the STRALES capability to fire DART guided ammunition specifically designed for the engagement of fast manoeuvrings targets, the VULCANO GPS-guided long-range ammunition able to engage a target with an excellent accuracy as well as the Multi Feeding (MF) device for the ammunition automatic handling. Recently, the OTO 76/62, which has been developed more efficient and effective, has successfully completed a cyber assessment that guarantees the product against any hostile cyber-attacks, particularly threatening in increasingly sophisticated systems. http://www.leonardocompany.com/en/-/k130-oto76-super-rapid-corvettes
21 juin 2019 | International, C4ISR

Inmarsat awarded $246M contract for satellite services
By: Nathan Strout Inmarsat Government Inc. has been awarded a contract worth as much as $246 million over five years to provide commercial satellite communication services for the U.S. military. The single-award blanket purchase agreement with the Defense Information Systems Agency was announced June 18. The initial award covers a one-year span from June 19 to June 18, 2020, with four option years. The contract provides for commercial satellite bandwidth for U.S. Africa Command. “The government expects to order Ku-band services sufficient to support airborne intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance and command and control missions,” a DISA spokesperson said in an email June 20. According to the announcement, DISA received two bids for the contract. Inmarsat declined to comment on the award until after the protest period was over. The company has faced issues due to protests in the recent past. In September 2015, DISA awarded Inmarsat a potential five-year $450 million contract to provide worldwide commercial telecommunications services on the Ku, Ka and X-Band for the Navy's Commercial Broadband Satellite Program. That award was protested by Intelsat, who successfully convinced the Government Accountability Office that DISA had given different companies different bid requirements. That decision led to a stop-work order on the new contract, though DISA ultimately lifted the stop work order through a contract modification in July 2016. A DISA spokesperson confirmed that the two contracts are not mission related. https://www.c4isrnet.com/battlefield-tech/2019/06/20/inmarsat-awarded-246-million-contract-for-satellite-services/

Toutes les nouvelles