20 février 2020 | Local, Aérospatial, Naval, Terrestre, C4ISR, Sécurité

New defence procurement agency would be disruptive, costly

New defence procurement agency would be disruptive, costly

It almost seemed like a throwaway line at the end of the Liberal Party's 2019 election platform, in a section on proposed approaches to security: “To ensure that Canada's biggest and most complex defence procurement projects are delivered on time and with greater transparency to Parliament, we will move forward with the creation of Defence Procurement Canada.”

Little was said about the proposal during the election campaign, but in the mandate letters to ministers that followed, National Defence (DND), Public Services and Procurement (PSPC), and Fisheries, Oceans and the Canadian Coast Guard were tasked with bringing forward options to establish Defence Procurement Canada (DPC), a priority, the Prime Minister wrote, “to be developed concurrently with ongoing procurement projects and existing timelines.”

Whether DPC would be a department, standalone agency or new entity within an existing department isn't clear. Nor is it apparent how the government would consolidate and streamline the myriad procurement functions of multiple departments.

Jody Thomas, deputy minister of National Defence, acknowledged as much during an address to the Canadian Global Affairs Institute (CGAI) Jan. 29 when asked about DPC progress.

“I don't know what it is going to look like ... We're building a governance to look at what the options could be and we are studying what other countries have done,” she said, noting that a standalone agency outside the department of defence has not necessarily worked particularly well in other countries. “Everything is on the table. We're looking at it, but we haven't actually begun the work in earnest.”

The idea of moving defence procurement under a single point of accountability is hardly new. Alan Williams, a former assistant deputy minister of Material (Adm Mat), made the case for a single agency in a 2006 book, Reinventing Canadian Defence Procurement. And the Canadian Association of Defence and Security Industries (CADSI) issued a report in 2009 calling for a “separate defence procurement agency reporting through a single Minister ... [to] consolidate procurement, industrial, contracting and trade mandates into one new department, like a Defence Production Department, reporting to a minister.”

More recently, an interim report on defence procurement by the Senate Committee on National Defence in June 2019 argued that “a single agency could simplify the complex procurement governance framework. Serious consideration could also be given to empowering project officials and making the Department of National Defence the lead department.”

Williams remains a strong proponent. In a presentation to a CGAI conference on defence procurement in the new Parliament in late November, he greeted the DPC decision with a “hallelujah,” pointing to the high cost created by overlap and duplication when multiple ministers are involved in a military acquisition decision, and the tendency to play the “blame game” when delays or problems arise and there is no single point of accountability.

But he cautioned that the initiative would falter without better system-wide performance measures on cost, schedules and other metrics. “If you don't monitor and put public pressure on the system, things will [slide],” he said.

Williams also called for a defence industrial plan, backed by Cabinet approval, to help identify where to invest defence capital, and “a culture that recognizes and demands innovative creativity, taking chances.”

Other former senior civil servants, many with decades of experience in public sector organizational reform, were less optimistic about the prospects of a new agency or departmental corporation.

“There is always a good reason why things are the way they are,” said Jim Mitchell, a research associate with the Graduate School of Public and International Affairs at the University of Ottawa and part of massive reorganization of government departments undertaken by Prime Minister Kim Campbell during her brief tenure in 1993.

“If you want to change things, you first have to understand, why do we have the current situation that we have in defence procurement and who are the people who have a major stake in the status quo and why? If you don't understand that, you are going to get into big trouble,” he warned the CGAI audience of government and industry leaders.

At a time when the departments are moving a record number of equipment projects, including CF-188 Hornet replacement, through the acquisition process under the government's 2017 defence policy, any restructuring could significantly delay progress.

“Organizational change is always disruptive, it's costly, it's difficult, it's hard on people, it hurts efficiency and effectiveness of organizations for a couple of years at minimum,” said Mitchell. “It is something you do very, very carefully.”

It's a point not lost on CADSI. “The sheer scale of the change required to make DPC real should give companies pause. It could involve some 4,000-6,000 government employees from at least three departments and multiple pieces of legislation, all while the government is in the middle of the most aggressive defence spending spree in a generation,” the association wrote in an email to members in December.

A vocal proponent of improving procurement, it called DPC “a leap of faith,” suggesting it might be “a gamble that years of disruption will be worth it and that the outcomes of a new system will produce measurably better results, including for industry.”

Gavin Liddy, a former assistant deputy minister with PSPC, questioned the reasoning for change when measures from earlier procurement reform efforts such as increased DND contracting authority up to $5 million are still taking effect.

“You really need an extraordinarily compelling reason to make any kind of organizational change. And every time we have attempted it ... it takes five to seven years before the organization is up and standing on its feet,” he told CGAI. “If you want to do one single thing to delay the defence procurement agenda...create a defence procurement agency. Nothing would divert attention more than doing that.”

While few questioned the need for enhancements to the defence procurement process, many of the CGAI participants raised doubts about the logic of introducing a new entity less than three years into the government's 20-year strategy. Thomas described a number of improvements to project management and governance that are already making a difference.

“The budgeting and project management in defence is really extraordinarily well done. If I am told by ADM Mat they are going to spend $5.2 billion, then that is what they spend. And we have the ability to bring more down, or less, depending on how projects are rolling,” she explained. “We are completely transparent about how we are getting money spent, what the milestones are on projects ... The program management board is functioning differently and pulling things forward instead of waiting until somebody is ready to push it forward.”

“And we are working with PSPC. I think it is time to look at the government contracting [regulations], how much we compete, what we sole source, the reasons we sole source. I think there is a lot of work there that can be done that will improve the system even more.”


Sur le même sujet

  • Dévoilement de la nouvelle stratégie spatiale pour le Canada - Le gouvernement dévoile son plan pour l'avenir de l'exploration spatiale, des sciences de l'espace et des emplois dans ce domaine

    14 mars 2019 | Local, Aérospatial

    Dévoilement de la nouvelle stratégie spatiale pour le Canada - Le gouvernement dévoile son plan pour l'avenir de l'exploration spatiale, des sciences de l'espace et des emplois dans ce domaine

    EDMONTON, le 6 mars 2019 /CNW/ - Qu'il s'agisse de mettre au point des technologies satellitaires avant-gardistes, de construire le Canadarm ou de déployer des systèmes de radar spatiaux, le Canada exerce un leadership en matière de sciences et de technologies spatiales depuis plus de 60 ans. Les investissements dans les sciences, l'innovation et la recherche ouvrent de nouveaux horizons de croissance économique, créent des milliers d'emplois pour des Canadiens travaillants, et nous aident à mieux comprendre le monde dans lequel nous vivons et la place que nous y occupons. Le ministre de l'Innovation, des Sciences et du Développement économique, l'honorable Navdeep Bains, a dévoilé aujourd'hui la nouvelle stratégie spatiale pour le Canada, qui met l'accent sur la valeur stratégique de l'espace et de l'exploration spatiale pour le Canada. L'engagement du Canada à participer au projet du Gateway lunaire constitue la pièce maîtresse de la stratégie, qui est intitulée Exploration, imagination, innovation : Une nouvelle stratégie spatiale pour le Canada. La stratégie qui vise à exploiter des créneaux forts de notre pays, comme la robotique, tout en faisant avancer les sciences et l'innovation dans des domaines de pointe comme l'intelligence artificielle (IA) et les technologies biomédicales. En outre, pour préparer la prochaine génération à occuper les emplois de demain, l'initiative Astronautes juniors misera sur le pouvoir d'inspiration de l'espace pour amener les jeunes à s'intéresser aux sciences, aux technologies, à l'ingénierie et aux mathématiques, qui s'inscrivent dans le large éventail de compétences et d'activités liées à l'espace. La stratégie décrit comment le gouvernement entend positionner l'industrie spatiale canadienne pour tirer pleinement profit de l'économie mondiale croissante dans le domaine spatial, tout en assurant que le Canada tire son épingle du jeu. Dans le cadre de la stratégie, les entreprises innovatrices du secteur spatial recevront l'appui d'un programme d'investissement qui leur est réservé, ce qui leur permettra de croître et de prospérer au Canada et à l'étranger. La stratégie met aussi la priorité sur l'exploitation des sciences et des technologies de l'espace pour résoudre des enjeux importants sur Terre, et propose notamment ce qui suit : Investir dans les technologies de communication par satellite pour la large bande, notamment pour assurer la connectivité dans les régions rurales et éloignées; Étudier comment dispenser de meilleure façon les services de soins de santé dans les communautés éloignées au moyen des leçons apprises dans l'espace; Financer la mise au point et la démonstration de sciences et de technologies lunaires dans divers domaines notamment l'IA, la robotique et la santé; Mettre à profit les données uniques recueillies à l'aide des ressources spatiales canadiennes pour appuyer la croissance des entreprises et mener des activités scientifiques de pointe, y compris en ce qui a trait aux incidences des changements climatiques sur l'atmosphère. L'exploration spatiale nous permet de mieux comprendre notre planète et l'Univers, tout en favorisant la recherche et les découvertes et en ouvrant de nouvelles possibilités commerciales au Canada qui rehausseront la qualité de vie de la population. Le gouvernement du Canada mettra la stratégie à profit pour appuyer les prochaines générations d'innovateurs et d'explorateurs, et pour donner aux Canadiens les moyens de décrocher les emplois de demain dans des industries d'avenir. Les faits en bref La stratégie tient compte des perspectives et des points de vue recueillis par le Comité consultatif de l'espace. Le 28 février 2019, le gouvernement du Canada a annoncé un investissement de 1,9 milliard de dollars sur 24 ans dans la prochaine génération de robotique spatiale intelligente alimentée par l'IA pour le Gateway lunaire, un projet dirigé par les États-Unis. Le gouvernement a aussi fourni 150 millions de dollars sur cinq ans à l'appui du Programme d'accélération de l'exploration lunaire (PAEL). Le PAEL financera le développement et la démonstration de sciences et de technologies lunaires dans divers domaines notamment l'IA, la robotique et la santé. L'initiative Astronautes juniors propose des activités et un concours en vue d'offrir une formation à des jeunes au siège social de l'Agence spatiale canadienne à Saint-Hubert, au Québec, en compagnie de véritables astronautes. Le secteur canadien de l'espace emploie 10 000 travailleurs hautement qualifiés. Il génère 5,5 milliards de dollars par année dans l'économie canadienne, et représente, en moyenne, 2 milliards de dollars de ventes à l'exportation. L'espace est une source de débouchés commerciaux lucratifs pour nos entreprises. Morgan Stanley prévoit que le marché mondial de l'espace triplera pour atteindre 1,1 billion de dollars américains à l'horizon 2040. Le gouvernement du Canada a investi plus de 2,5 milliards de dollars depuis 2015 dans le secteur spatial canadien. Il a entre autres prolongé la participation du Canada aux missions à bord de la Station spatiale internationale, fourni du financement à l'Agence spatiale canadienne pour mettre à l'essai des technologies spatiales et aidé des entreprises canadiennes à prendre de l'expansion par l'entremise du Fonds stratégique pour l'innovation. « En visant la Lune, nous inspirons nos enfants à se tourner vers la conquête des étoiles. L'espace est synonyme de possibilités illimitées et de découvertes infinies. Derrière chaque astronaute que nous envoyons dans l'espace se trouvent des milliers de Canadiens qui contribuent au succès de sa mission. La stratégie spatiale saura inspirer notre prochaine génération d'astronautes, d'ingénieurs et de scientifiques. Elle fera aussi en sorte que la population et les entreprises du Canada profitent des débouchés croissants qu'offre l'économie de l'espace. » L'honorable Navdeep Bains, ministre de l'Innovation, des Sciences et du Développement économique Liens connexes Stratégie spatiale pour le Canada (pdf) Gateway lunaire Astronautes juniors Comité consultatif de l'espace Fonds stratégique pour l'innovation Site Web : http://asc-csa.gc.ca Courriel : ASC.Medias-Media.CSA@canada.ca Suivez-nous sur les médias sociaux SOURCE Agence spatiale canadienne https://www.newswire.ca/fr/news-releases/devoilement-de-la-nouvelle-strategie-spatiale-pour-le-canada-le-gouvernement-devoile-son-plan-pour-l-avenir-de-l-exploration-spatiale-des-sciences-de-l-espace-et-des-emplois-dans-ce-domaine-899923430.html

  • Maxar Technologies' MDA to Provide Design Services for the Electronic Warfare Suite for the Canadian Surface Combatant

    1 avril 2019 | Local, Naval

    Maxar Technologies' MDA to Provide Design Services for the Electronic Warfare Suite for the Canadian Surface Combatant

    MDA continues positive momentum to provide game-changing defence capabilities MONTREAL, April 1, 2019 /CNW/ - MDA, a Maxar company (NYSE: MAXR) (TSX: MAXR), today announced that it has signed a CAD $4 million contract with Lockheed Martin Canada for the initial phase of design work for the Canadian Surface Combatant (CSC) ship's Electronic Warfare system. Lockheed Martin Canada was selected as the winning bidder for the CSC program by Irving Shipbuilding. Irving Shipbuilding is the CSC Prime Contractor and will build 15 ships at Halifax Shipyard. This design work is expected to become the basis for the manufacture, integration, installation and commissioning of the Electronic Warfare equipment on the Royal Canadian Navy's next-generation CSC ships. "MDA is very pleased to be able to play such a critical role in supplying systems for the Canadian Surface Combatant program," said Mike Greenley, group president of MDA. "We are proud to support Lockheed Martin Canada by leveraging MDA's deep Canadian expertise in project management, system engineering, electronics, antennas, signal processing and software. This initial contract represents the first phase of what we anticipate will become a decades-long journey as a tier-1 partner on the Lockheed Martin Canada team." The CSC is a globally deployable, multi-role warship designed to meet the distinctive mission requirements of the Royal Canadian Navy. MDA is partnered with other industry leaders including BAE Systems, CAE, Lockheed Martin Canada, L3 Technologies and Ultra Electronics as Canada'sCombat Ship Team to provide the Royal Canadian Navy the most advanced and modern warship design. Purposely designed for anti-submarine warfare and capable of performing a variety of missions in any part of the world, the CSC is acoustically quiet, versatile, highly survivable, and reconfigurable for future modernization. The most recent Canadian Defence Policy stated that 15 of these ships will be built in Canada over the next 25 years and will serve the Royal Canadian Navy for decades to come. About Maxar Technologies As a global leader of advanced space technology solutions, Maxar is at the nexus of the new space economy, developing and sustaining the infrastructure and delivering the information, services, systems that unlock the promise of space for commercial and government markets. The operations of DigitalGlobe, SSL and Radiant Solutions were unified under the Maxar brand in February; MDA continues to operate as an independent business unit within the Maxar organization. As a trusted partner with 5,900 employees in over 30 global locations, Maxar provides vertically integrated capabilities and expertise including satellites, Earth imagery, robotics, geospatial data and analytics to help customers anticipate and address their most complex mission-critical challenges with confidence. Every day, billions of people rely on Maxar to communicate, share information and data, and deliver insights that Build a Better World. Maxar trades on the New York Stock Exchange and Toronto Stock Exchange as MAXR. For more information, visit www.maxar.com. Forward-Looking Statements Certain statements and other information included in this release constitute "forward-looking information" or "forward-looking statements" (collectively, "forward-looking statements") under applicable securities laws. Statements including words such as "may", "will", "could", "should", "would", "plan", "potential", "intend", "anticipate", "believe", "estimate" or "expect" and other words, terms and phrases of similar meaning are often intended to identify forward-looking statements, although not all forward-looking statements contain these identifying words. Forward-looking statements involve estimates, expectations, projections, goals, forecasts, assumptions, risks and uncertainties, as well as other statements referring to or including forward-looking information included in this press release. Forward-looking statements are subject to various risks and uncertainties which could cause actual results to differ materially from the anticipated results or expectations expressed in this release. As a result, although management of the Company believes that the expectations and assumptions on which such forward-looking statements are based are reasonable, undue reliance should not be placed on the forward-looking statements because the Company can give no assurance that they will prove to be correct. The risks that could cause actual results to differ materially from current expectations include, but are not limited to, the risk factors and other disclosures about the Company and its business included in the Company's continuous disclosure materials filed from time to time with Canadian and U.S. securities regulatory authorities, which are available online under the Company's EDGAR profile at www.sec.gov, under the Company's SEDAR profile at www.sedar.com or on the Company's website at www.maxar.com. The forward-looking statements contained in this release are expressly qualified in their entirety by the foregoing cautionary statements. All such forward-looking statements are based upon data available as of the date of this release or other specified date and speak only as of such date. The Company disclaims any intention or obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements in this release as a result of new information or future events, except as may be required under applicable securities legislation. Contact Leslie Swartman | MDA Media Contact | 1-613-736-6917| leslie.swartman@mdacorporation.com Jason Gursky | Maxar Investor Relations | 1-303-684-2207 | jason.gursky@maxar.com SOURCE Maxar Technologies Ltd. https://www.newswire.ca/news-releases/maxar-technologies-mda-to-provide-design-services-for-the-electronic-warfare-suite-for-the-canadian-surface-combatant-877885915.html

  • CAE USA a signé un contrat de sous-traitance avec Lockheed Martin afin d'appuyer l'élaboration de dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes

    20 novembre 2017 | Local, Aérospatial

    CAE USA a signé un contrat de sous-traitance avec Lockheed Martin afin d'appuyer l'élaboration de dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes

    Tampa (Floride, États-Unis), le 20 november 2017, 2017 - (NYSE : CAE; TSX : CAE) - CAE USA a remporté un contrat de sous-traitance de Lockheed Martin visant à appuyer la conception, l'élaboration et la fabrication de six dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes (WST) pour l'appareil C-130J de la United States Air Force et de la Air National Guard américaine. La commande de ces six dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes pour l'appareil C-130J a été reçue au cours du deuxième trimestre de l'exercice financier 2018 et a été incluse à l'annonce de revenus trimestriels effectuée le 10 novembre 2017. « Nous sommes heureux de poursuivre notre partenariat de longue date avec Lockheed Martin pour la conception et l'élaboration de systèmes de formation relatifs à l'appareil Super Hercules C-130J », a déclaré Ray Duquette, président et directeur général de CAE USA. « Les capacités haute fidélité de ces dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes pour l'appareil C-130J permettent aux Forces aériennes d'intégrer de plus en plus la formation virtuelle à leur programme de formation global, ce qui, en fin de compte, favorise la sécurité, l'efficacité et l'état de préparation aux missions pour les équipages. » Les dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes pour le C-130J sont des simulateurs de mission à système de mouvement complet qui simulent avec exactitude l'appareil et ses diverses missions. Les simulateurs recréent les sons, le mouvement, l'environnement virtuel et tous les autres systèmes requis pour fournir un environnement de formation en vol haute fidélité et réaliste. En 2020 et en 2021, ces six dispositifs d'entraînement aux systèmes d'armes pour l'appareil C-130J seront livrés à diverses bases aériennes. http://www.cae.com/CAE-USA-awarded-subcontract-from-Lockheed-Martin-to-support-development-of-C-130J-weapon-systems-trainers/?LangType=1036

Toutes les nouvelles