10 mai 2019 | Local, Aérospatial

ASSESSING THE DAMAGE FROM CANADA’S FIGHTER REPLACEMENT FIASCO: NEW MLI REPORT

OTTAWA, ON (May 6, 2019): In a hard-hitting new Macdonald-Laurier Institute report, MLI Senior Fellow Richard Shimooka takes a critical look at the government's approach to replacing Canada's aging fleet of CF-18 fighters. In the report, titled The Catastrophe: Assessing the Damage from Canada's Fighter Replacement Fiasco, he argues that Ottawa's performance on this file mirrors the SNC-Lavalin Scandal and the Mark Norman Affair.

“At their heart, these two incidents represent attempts by the Liberal government to circumvent established processes to meet their partisan interests,” Shimooka explains. “This description is just as apt for the fighter program.”

Canada is a participant in the Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) Program that has been developing the F-35s. These fighter jets were slotted to replace the RCAF's aging CF-18s, but after the program was mired in political scandal under the previous government, the Liberal government changed plans.

“During the 2015 election campaign, the Liberal Party promised not to buy the F-35 jets, but instead to use a competition to identify and subsequently purchase a lower-cost competitor... this decision proved to be impossible, unethical, and potentially illegal,” writes Shimooka.

From billions of dollars being wasted on a procurement process to fix a contrived capability gap to potentially threatening Canada's defence relationship with the US, the report finds that political interests have consistently been put above Canada's defence needs.

Shimooka argues that “the decisions made [regarding fighter jet replacement] were purely for reasons of political interest: not a single one could be claimed as being in the country's national interest.”

The “fiasco,” as Shimooka describes it, has caught the attention of both Canada's Office of the Auditor General (OAG) and senior US officials. According to documents never before seen by the public, the OAG had specifically cautioned the government against its chosen course of purchasing Australian Hornets as an interim measure in a draft report – and the final OAG report was heavily revised to obscure that recommendation.

Worse still, letters from US officials reveal that “resentment and distrust towards the government of Canada had grown, particularly within the US Air Force.” These letters, which again have not been made public until now, outline the significant strategic and economic benefits that have already been accrued from being part of the JSF Program. Yet they also contain an implicit (but clear) threat that Canada could be kicked out of the Program – if Ottawa continues with its current policy of trying to obtain guaranteed industrial benefits that, by their very nature, are not allowed under the JSF Program.

“There was a complete lack of logic of Canada's policy, which seemed to ignore basic facts about membership in the JSF program, including clear advantages in cost and capability that the F-35 provided.”

Despite these persistent, high-level issues with the government's chosen approach on the fighter jet replacement, the file has avoided serious public scrutiny. Shimooka finds that this happened in large part due to the successful gag orders levelled by the government.

“The government has also suppressed negative viewpoints within and outside the Department of National Defence, allegedly up to and including the deletion of portions of Memos to Cabinet that highlighted why certain decisions should not be taken.”

Moving forward on the file may prove to be difficult; defence procurement woes have plagued Canada since Confederation, and the issues with the fighter jet replacement are deeper than just purchasing the right aircraft. Worse still, Shimooka says that the brunt of the burden of consistently poor decision-making in Ottawa will be borne by the RCAF itself.

“While the negative consequences are clear for Canada as a whole," Shimooka explains, "no community has felt the impact more than the RCAF. As a result of this government's policies, its ability to conduct its most basic function, the defence of Canadian sovereignty and that of our allies, is diminishing rapidly.”

“It is a sad state of affairs.”

To read the commentary in full, click here.

https://www.macdonaldlaurier.ca/assessing-damage-canadas-fighter-replacement-fiasco-new-mli-report/

Sur le même sujet

23 janvier 2019 | Local, Aérospatial, Naval, Terrestre, C4ISR, Sécurité

Les jeunes entreprises innovantes du Québec sont invitées à participer au Défi propulsion DEC
Le gouvernement du Canada accordera jusqu'à 500 000 $ à des jeunes entreprises innovantes du Québec Le 23 janvier 2019 – Montréal (Québec) – Développement économique Canada pour les régions du Québec (DEC) L'audace et l'ingéniosité des jeunes entrepreneurs innovants sont essentielles pour propulser le Québec dans l'économie de demain. C'est pourquoi le gouvernement du Canada lance aujourd'hui une nouvelle initiative pour les aider à concrétiser leurs projets d'affaires : le Défi propulsion DEC. Ce concours permettra aux jeunes entrepreneurs dynamiques de saisir les occasions offertes par des conditions économiques et technologiques en constante évolution. En lançant aujourd'hui le Défi, le ministre des Transports et député de Notre-Dame-de-Gr'ce—Westmount, l'honorable Marc Garneau, invite les jeunes de partout au Québec ayant la fibre entrepreneuriale et qui œuvrent dans les secteurs de pointe à soumettre, du 8 février au 1er avril 2019, leur plan d'affaires à Développement économique Canada pour les régions du Québec (DEC). En mai 2019, 20 entreprises finalistes seront invitées à présenter les projets les plus prometteurs à un jury d'experts. Les 10 meilleurs projets se verront remettre un prix de 50 000 $ pour concrétiser leur projet d'affaires. Les détails du Défi sont disponibles au canada.ca/defi-propulsion-dec. Citations « Le talent, particulièrement le talent entrepreneurial, est une importante ressource. Nous voulons favoriser l'émergence de nouvelles entreprises en investissant directement dans le développement des talents et des habiletés des Québécoises et des Québécois. Par cette initiative, notre gouvernement permettra à des jeunes de tous les coins du Québec de lancer leur entreprise et de concrétiser leur projet. » L'honorable Marc Garneau, député de Notre-Dame-de-Gr'ce—Westmount et ministre des Transports « Des initiatives comme le Défi propulsion DEC stimulent les entreprises innovantes à concrétiser leurs projets. En se dotant de la Stratégie fédérale d'innovation et de croissance pour les régions du Québec, le gouvernement du Canada a mis en place une approche ambitieuse pour stimuler l'innovation et la croissance pour tous. Il s'agit d'un engagement ferme pour contribuer au développement d'une culture d'innovation et, à terme, à la création de plus d'emplois de qualité pour les Québécois. » L'honorable Navdeep Bains, ministre responsable de DEC Faits en bref L'annonce d'aujourd'hui est faite au nom de l'honorable Navdeep Bains, ministre responsable du portefeuille de l'Innovation, des Sciences et du Développement économique, qui regroupe 17 ministères et organismes fédéraux, dont DEC et les cinq autres agences de développement régional. Le Défi propulsion DEC est une initiative qui découle de la Stratégie fédérale d'innovation et de croissance pour les régions du Québec. Pilotée par DEC, avec la participation d'autres ministères fédéraux, la Stratégie cible quatre priorités et quatorze pistes d'intervention pour favoriser l'adoption et le développement de pratiques innovatrices et assurer la croissance pour tous et pour toutes les régions du Québec. Les fonds ont été consentis en vertu du programme Croissance économique régionale par l'innovation (CERI) de DEC. Pour en savoir davantage sur DEC et ses priorités, consultez le Plan ministériel 2018-2019 ou visitez le www.dec-ced.gc.ca. Depuis maintenant 50 ans, le gouvernement du Canada participe activement au développement économique régional au Québec : un demi-siècle d'actions concrètes consacrées à l'essor des régions et des entreprises d'ici. https://www.canada.ca/fr/developpement-economique-regions-quebec/nouvelles/2019/01/les-jeunes-entreprises-innovantes-du-quebec-sont-invitees-a-participer-au-defi-propulsion-dec.html
6 avril 2021 | Local, Aérospatial

Remplacement des avions CF-18 | Ottawa devrait faire son choix en 2022
La saga des nouveaux avions de chasse pour l’armée canadienne, qui dure depuis plus de dix ans, devrait trouver un certain dénouement l’an prochain, malgré les défis et les retards dus à la pandémie, selon le sous-ministre responsable du dossier.
11 octobre 2018 | Local, Aérospatial

Purchase of three spy planes from the U.S. could cost Canada $140 million more than planned
DAVID PUGLIESE, OTTAWA CITIZEN Canadian companies had wanted to provide the aircraft, but the Canadian military decided it needed the planes quicker than they believed Canadian firms could deliver The cost of three small surveillance aircraft Canada is buying from the U.S. could be $140 million more than the Canadian military had originally estimated. The three Beechcraft King Air planes, to be based at CFB Trenton in Ontario, will be outfitted with sensors and equipment to intercept cell phone and other electronic transmissions. Canadian special forces and, potentially, other government departments will use them for missions overseas and in Canada. On Oct. 1 the Canadian Forces told Postmedia the three outfitted planes and initial in-service support would cost between $100 million and $249 million, as outlined in the Liberal government's defence policy documents. However, on Oct. 4 the U.S. Defense Security Cooperation Agency revealed the final tally, informing Congress that the deal was underway with an estimated cost of US $300 million — around $389 million. Canadian companies had wanted to provide the aircraft and on-board equipment, and several have formed alliances with U.S. firms who supply the Pentagon with the same or similar aircraft. But the Canadian military decided it needed the planes more quickly than they believed Canadian companies could deliver, and that U.S. security regulations governing the on-board sensor equipment might cause delays. As a result, it determined the U.S. government was the only supplier capable of providing the planes. The Canadian Forces says it hopes to get a better deal. The cost the U.S. government agency presented to Congress is not the final tally and the “final cost is anticipated to be much lower,” the Canadian Forces claimed in an email. “Over the coming months, we will work to more clearly define our interests and requirements for the purchase, and negotiate an acceptable price with the U.S.,” the email said. Department of National Defence spokeswoman Ashley Lemire said in an email to Postmedia that the delivery of the first plane would take place sometime between 2020 and 2021. The final delivery of the three aircraft would be wrapped up by 2022. The main contractor is Beechcraft in Wichita, Kan. The Canadian government will run a separate program to allow companies to compete to provide in-service support for the planes. The government expects to ask for bids for that 20-year contract sometime in the spring of 2019, said Lemire. DND declined to provide an estimate of what that long-term support would cost taxpayers. Industry representatives have complained over the years that the Canadian Forces cut domestic firms out of the project and reduced the role they could play. Lemire rejected that claim, saying Canadian firms would have a role in servicing the planes. https://calgaryherald.com/news/purchase-of-three-spy-planes-from-the-u-s-will-cost-canada-140-million-more-than-planned

Toutes les nouvelles